Pitch Perfect star Anna Kendrick made some musical magic with James Corden on Wednesday’s The Late Late Show. Except this time, the singing didn’t happen on a Carpool Karaoke ride — instead, the performing duo offered audiences a medley of popular love songs and acted out scenes to what they called ‘Soundtrack of a Love Story’.

In true rom com fashion, Kendrick and Corden sang songs about feelings at every stage in a relationship — from getting ready for a date (Dionne Warwick’s ‘I Say a Little Prayer’) to consummating their romance (Boyz II Men’s ‘I’ll Make Love to You’) to some more difficult times later on down the line (Shaggy’s ‘It Wasn’t Me’). It was epic and amazing.

This wasn’t the first time this musical theatre dream team appeared together on the screen — Kendrick and Corden were both apart of the ensemble cast of Disney’s Into the Woods.

Now let’s move onto the video. Watch it below:

Image credit: YouTube